Are you in the wrapper business?

-

We all are familiar with wrappers. It comes in all forms.

There is a chance that you recognize a product mostly by the wrapping. You may want to disagree. But, honestly, many a time you buy the wrapper and not the product.



You paid Rs 300 for the music CD that you bought last week. Now, it is very unlikely that you will pay that amount to just few songs once the labeled CD and its beautiful cover is removed. You may still take the music, but you may not buy it.

You are most likely to open and read through a document arrived on your desk in a FedEx envelop than one received through mail though the content could be perfectly conveyed through a mail. A FedEx envelope has made the document look more important.


Surely, the wrapping has done the difference.

               LETS BUY THE WINE, AND NOT THE BOTTLE


Seth Godin analyses the increasing chasm between wrappers and contents in his book ‘Small is the new big’. He says; “if your company makes contents, get out of the wrapper business as fast as you possibly can.” Seth Godin is one of the most influential thinkers today and his blog www.sethgodin.com is one of the most widely read in the world.

As a product, architecture is increasingly getting ‘wrapped’ up all around the world. Starchitects play a major role by specializing in the wrapping part of it. Read more about how this has more takers in ‘Fashion in architecture’.

Sure, one cannot ignore the wrappers completely as people often attach emotional values with it. But when wrappers are given more merit and importance than the content, along with the general public, even architectural community starts believing in it.



Many a times I have urged my younger architectural friends to imagine stripping of a beautiful space of its skins and plug-ins and see whether the space evokes the same feeling. Even if the answer is a lowly yes, it may be considered as a quality design. But interestingly, most of the time, we are in for sad surprises.

Lets dream for a future society that gives more value to content than to its wrappers.

Lets buy the wine and not the bottle.!

Comments

  1. jills philipOctober 30, 2012 at 10:48 PM

    very relevant post binu.. happy that you thought of this, while the entire world seems to be gravitating away from content. cheers!

    ReplyDelete
  2. jills philipOctober 30, 2012 at 10:50 PM

    by the way, now that u've told about wine & wine bottle paradigm, check out the domus winery bldg by herzog & demeuron....

    ReplyDelete
  3. Binu BalakrishnanOctober 30, 2012 at 11:31 PM

    Jills, you are right... and its easy to pick examples! Its a sad plight not only in architecture but also in product design (burgeoning smart phone market, say), publishing, service industry and even in presidential elections.! Though it would be suicidal to ignore the wrapper part completely, content should invariably be given more importance.

    @Domus winery bldg: interesting share :) remember reading it in architectural record earlier. Thanks for the comments.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Make Sure it's Your Train

-
Image
Accept it. Student architects are always confused about choosing the right career path. It gets all the more complicated with myriad options (and specializations) available today. Though the scene has changed a lot, I think the speech by Charles Correa more than a decade ago ( Convocation Address at the School of Planning and Architecture, New Delhi, 1996 ) still is very relevant. I want to share his thoughts as a continuation of my post  'architecture as a profession' . His observations are sharp, as usual, and I am sure that any architect at any stage of his career will get useful (if not motivating) insights from the speech. Extracts from his talk are given below.     “How much we grow depends on the issues we have the good fortune to address. This brings to mind a story told to me by Arvind Talati, a young Indian architect who followed Doshi at Corbusier's office in Paris. After working for two years or so, when Talati decided to return to lndi
Read the complete post »

Revisiting Le Corbusier’s MOA building

-
Image
World has just celebrated 125 th birthday of one of the most influential architect of the 20 th century, Le Corbusier. This reminded me of my visit to the much famous Millowner's Association Building in Ahmedabad a few years back. There are few cities in the world that can claim more than three buildings by Le  Corbusier, and Ahmedabad is one of them(after Paris, Chandigarh and La Chaux-de-Fonds), with the Museum, the Millowners Association Building, and the Sarabhai and Shodhan houses to its credit. Such major commissions, all initiated during Le Corbusier’s first visit to the city, attest to Ahmedabad’s intellectual climate and economic prosperity unrivalled in India for a city of its size. A comparative visual study by Peter Serenyi, comparing the Hall of Public Audiences, Red Fort and the Assembly building, Chandigarh hinting on the inspirations of the architect for his public buildings. Since its founding by Sultan Ahmed, Shah of Gujrat in 1411 AD, A
Read the complete post »

Architects and sketching

-
Image
Architects are associated with sketching long before the profession has evolved. One automatically expects an architect to sketch and explain his point. Architectural career choices are still majorly influenced by the candidate’s proficiency in sketching . Is the skill heavily overrated? Or does it deserve the hype? The problem starts when one confuses sketching with ‘art’. Definitely, creativity (and thus similar tastes) has its own part in shaping an architect’s career. But what one forgets in the debate is the potential of a ‘ skill’ as basic as sketching which can help the professional in a long way throughout his career. It is a skill which can be learnt and mastered. A very powerful ‘tool’ - sometimes the most powerful - which if used with care, can simplify many a process. It’s also a skill which is very enjoyable. "STRIPPING INFORMATION INTO THE VERY BASICS HAS HUGE ADVANTAGES."
Read the complete post »